Training and Instructional
Design
(Damocles to Dionysus!)
The Story of Damocles, Dionysus, and the Sword of Damocles
Here’s
a story that many of you must’ve heard before.
There was a king whose name was Dionysus
and like all kings he used to be surrounded by sycophants, who would
flatter him no end. Among his courtiers was an exceptionally brilliant
toady whose name was Damocles.
Now Damocles made it a point to butter Mr. Dionysus up at every
little speck of opportunity.
“Oh Dionysus the Greatest of the Great rulers of the very land
of ours (Syracuse, incidentally,) your palace is magnificent!” he
would rant. “Oh Dionysus, the scion of the most powerful Syracusan
dynasty, the opulence that I’ve seen here is incomparable,” Damocles
would chant!
So one day Dionysus decided that enough was enough…and he invited
Damocles over. Damocles arrived right in time, strutting like a
decorated peacock, expecting the unexpected. The unexpected did
happen… at least twice that evening. Dionysus asked Damocles whether
he’d like to own that fabulous palace with its fabulous contents
and experience the feeling of being rich, firsthand?
“Oh yes! Oh yes…yes…yes,” babbled Damocles. This was an unexpected
bounty! So Dionysus pronounced Damocles the lord of the whole palace
and whatever it contained! Damocles was so happy that he pirouetted
on his toes with his hands stretched out and leaped high in the
air as Dionysus watched him with an amused air.
Later when Damocles was finally able to contain his happiness,
they sat down to dine. Lovely nymphs danced to heavenly music. Handsome
men and beautiful women served them the food! Candles stood in ivory-gold
stands casting a golden glow over everything in the room while they
feasted on delicacies that were awe-inspiring (and of course, mouth-watering!)
Everything was fine…until Damocles saw something unnerving
in the reflection thrown off the polished surface of the golden
plate…there was something hanging over his neck! He gingerly looked
up…there sure was something – a sword that hung right over his neck
with a horsehair! Suddenly he lost interest in everything…all that
he remained aware of was that shiny sword hanging over his neck…the
sword that could fall off any minute to…”
“So…Damocles,” said Dionysus, “you know now how much I enjoy
what I have. Power, affluence, and position they all come with a
sword that hangs over your head all the time!”
Damocles was so tensed that he couldn’t comprehend anything;
he continued to stare up, as he sat in the golden throne paralyzed
with fear!
Cicero
originally told the Roman Philosopher this little story that I just
retold! He too had read it in a book, so you see, the history of
borrowing stories for making a point dates back to a long-long time.
But that’s not the point that I wish to make by telling this story.
In fact, this story makes a very strong point about the trainer’s
vulnerability in the current training scenario. It tells us that
each trainer has a Damocles sword hanging over his or her neck;
and that no amount of monetary or esteem rewards can remove the
chances of that sword falling down!
Trainers and the Sword of Damocles
We call this sword “change.” Most who work in the “Learning &
Development” divisions would know that “development” refers to the
continuous skill enhancement process that each of has to go through,
in order to make sure that we stay viable.
The Good, Old, Rusty Days of the Past
I can recall the days when the “Learning and Development divisions"
were called “Training Departments” and when a Trainer could relax
by being good at a certain set of skills all his (or her) life.
Things changed. I think that the primary catalyst in this change
has been the Internet. The Internet gave people and option to upgrade
their skills almost on a continuous basis…and some of these people
were trainers too.
Let us see how the change took place.
Then it all Changed!
Most trainers have excellent…almost magnetic personalities. They
have a great presence on the dais; and they speak really well. Now
these competencies are behavioral and have been developed through
years of practice. With these skills in place, differentiation between
trainers becomes a function of their knowledge. Unfortunately, due
to the nature of their profession and its requirements, Trainers
tend to pick knowledge-bits of diverse kinds. Thus they end up with
a shallow reservoir of knowledge, which isn’t enough to support
them through changes that require strong conceptual skills.
Over the last many years, while conducting Instructional
Design Courses and training programs, I’ve interacted with many
trainers. I’ve learned that most trainers are smart, bright, and
willing to learn. However, many prefer jargons to concepts and terms
to application. Their preference originates from their past experiences.
They’ve seen their participants being impressed with their huge
collection of examples and if you’d pardon my use of the term, jargons!
I believe that intelligence can be channeled in productive as well
as non-productive activities; and I firmly believe that if you really
want to do well in life, you must build your life on a strong foundation
that runs deep. Interesting bits of information such as the new
and the in terminology, are decorative elements that help
make your trainings interesting, but the effectiveness of a training
program is another matter altogether!
How to Stop being Damocles?
I know that I’ve spoken about something that we don’t often talk
about…but I hope to reach your inner, real self. I want you to review
your learning priorities to determine whether you’ve been channeling
your intelligence in the right direction. I believe that if you
want to transform every training program of yours into a learning
dream, learn
instructional design and use it to make your training programs powerful.
I suggest this to you because I’ve seen it transform me. Let me
tell you how it helps me.
I am in love with this fantastic discipline, and no, I am not a
theoretical person. It is the practicality of instructional design
that enchants me. I love to apply instructional design, without
diluting it…in its raw essence. I’ve seen it work! For me instructional
design is not a collection of theories and models, it is a living
discipline, which breathes through its application! For me, it changes
form with each project. When I commit mistakes (of course, I do)
I map them to the ID schema that I have in my mind – and I improve
the future trainings and courses that I work upon!
Do I go scouting for definitions and terminology? No I don’t…my
passion for instructional design captures the terminology and I
form my own definitions as I move through content creation. Those
definitions stay with me, because I formed them. Do I scamper around
on the web trying to find icebreakers and training games? No, I
don’t. My love for instructional design has made my learning go
deep; and so instructional design helps me create my own stories.
I don’t say that I wouldn’t squirrel away a great anecdote if I
came across it…I would…I have enough of the trainer-bug in me…but
I won’t go crazy trying to find the right one! I’d rather write
a story that would suit my purpose better! How? I would use instructional
design! Thus, I would strengthen my ID
skills further and further…until the Damocles Sword disappeared,
or my neck became ough enough to break the sword when it falls over
it.
Instructional Design - The Armor for a Trainer's Neck!
I know it from experience…there is no substitute for knowledge
that runs deep…and for us, the trainers, the knowledge that should
run deep within us, is that of instructional design. Why? Because
in the economic climate of today, a trainer can’t just train on
one kind of content…you need to keep the subject matter diverse
– so ensure that you become a master of weaving any type of content
into a training tapestry that takes the audience’s breath away!
The decision of course is yours. What’s that hackneyed old saying
– “You can take a horse to the water, but you can’t make him drink.”
I guess we must be talking of an adult horse here, because this
is exactly what andragogy says, albeit a bit positively. “Adult
learners display self-direction. They prefer to set the direction
for their own learning.” But yes, there is something that I would
like to say here…humans are smarter than horses! We prioritize.
So set your priorities. Decide whether you wish to find the right armor for your neck…for the sword shall continue to hang over your neck as long
as you continue to dream of becoming Dionysus; great, powerful,
and affluent. You’ve got to toughen up – you’ve got to stop being
Damocles – you’ve got to become Dionysus...who could keep his peace
of mind despite the sword.
In my opinion, there are only two ways to win your peace of mind
back – either become an island or toughen up…let your knowledge
of instructional design run deep, and let it guide your training
programs towards audience satisfaction.
- Author:
Shafali R. Anand
Read more Articles by Shafali:
- Jobs in this Changing, Evolving World (Jobs – 2020 to 2040)
- The AFR Learner Types – Learning in this Changing, Evolving World (The AFR Learning Types will define who will survive and thrive in 2020-2040.)
- Augmented Reality and its Application in Learning (AR vs. VR, Examples of AR, and how it will define the future of eLearning)
- How Emotional Intelligence Saves Creativity – The IRON Method (How to Identify, Repair, Open, and Nurture the Creative Connections between your Creative Expressions and your Emotions.)
- David Kolb’s Cycle of Experiential Learning (The Four Stages of Learning & The Four Learner Types)
- The Trainer's Rendezvous with eLearning (A Short Affair or a Long-lasting Relationship?)
- Gamification of Trainings and Learning Experiences (Old Wine in New Bottle? If it tastes great, who cares?)
- Gamification (What does this new-fangled, star-spangled term mean?)
- Storytelling and Instructional Design (How to Provide, Guide, and Reinforce Learning by Writing Instructional Stories.)
- 5 Rules of Content Writing - Learning from the Bible (How to Design, Develop, and Implement Courses and Trainings)
- Instructional Design Theory & Practice - The Gap (Using the ADDIE Lens to determine why Training Programs Fail.)
- Writing Scripts or Storyboards for eLearning Content without Losing your Mind (Beating the Fixated ID Syndrome)
- Designing Training Games to Rev up your Workshops! (The Challenges and The Rewards)
- Should you become an Instructional Designer? (4 Key Traits of a Content Writer for eLearning/Training)
- eLearning, Instructional Design, Technical Writing, And Training (The Maze of Hidden Relationships)
- Training and Instructional Design (Damocles to Dionysus!)
- Casting the Spell of Learner Motivation (How Content Writers and Trainers can Weave Magic for the Learners?)
- The ADDIE Model (An Instructional Designer's Road Map)
|
